With the market bouncing up and down on a daily basis, nerves are high. The question I get more than any other is whether or not this is a new bear market or just a bump in the road. I’m going to lay out some historical characteristics of bear markets vs. corrections in a bull market. In 2007, there were several signs that the market was beginning to deteriorate. It’s not just about looking at the level of the Dow Jones Industrials. During 2007, in addition to the economy beginning to slow down, the internals of the stock market were getting weaker. Anytime I analyze the NYSE, filtering through the various types of securities traded takes some time. Closed-end bond funds, REITS, preferred stocks, etc. are traded on the NYSE. Stripping those out and looking just at the operating companies gives an investor a much better sense of actual buying/selling and the future direction of the markets. In 2007, the number of companies making new highs began to fall while the ones making new lows started rising. In addition, the amount of volume (shares traded) was increasing on down days and falling on up days. Various stocks began to enter their own private bear market. Then, various sectors did the same. Eventually by 2008, the entire market was in a downturn that eventually snowballed into what amounted to a stock market crash. This progression that led to a new bear market was typical even though the drop in 2008 and the intensity were not. Bear markets such as this one tend to look like a lower case “n” where they roll over.
A correction, on the other hand, happens very rapidly, is news driven and very scary. As an trader and advisor, I tend to remember each year based on what the stock market does. I remember 1998 as though it was yesterday. In 1998, the stock market had started off the year very strong with 20% gains (based on the S&P 500) in just the first four months of the year. That was followed by a mild correction (5%). From the spring to midsummer, the S&P had gained another 10% and was at new highs. Just as quickly as the rally had started, it came to a violent end. What caused this abrupt turnaround? In August of 1998, Russia defaulted on its debt and the financial markets went into a tailspin. Long Term Capital Management (LTCM), a hedge fund collapsed. The Federal Reserve sponsored a bailout of LTCM by its creditor banks. The Fed intervened and said they were trying to prevent a financial crisis. Sound familiar? LTCM eventually liquidated in year 2000. In one month, the market had fallen 10%. For a month it bounced around these low levels until it eventually fell another 10% bringing the correction to 20% from peak to trough. It bounced 10% and eventually re-tested the lows. That was the end of the correction, not the beginning of a bear market.
I believe Russia in 1998 is today’s Greece. The stock market was in a well defined bull market and a 20% correction came virtually out of nowhere. However, it ended and the stock market went on to make new highs before eventually peaking in March of 2000.
Below, I’ve overlaid the 1998 stock market on top of our current stock market. There is a very similar pattern. But notice in August 1998 (blue line) how the market took an initial drop (10%), paused and took another leg down. I’m not necessarily predicting another 10% fall from these levels in the stock market, but it did happen in 1998 and that was a correction in a bull market, not the start of a bear market.

There are several instances over the past several decades of corrections that look very similar to what we’re experiencing in the markets in 2010. With that said, there are several headwinds today that are different from 1998. In 1998, we were dealing with taxes heading down, corporate profits rising, interest rates in a long-term downtrend, and a more peaceful geopolitical environment. Therefore, there are more doubters of the recent rally than in 1998 and justifiably so. It’s important to constantly monitor the overall strength of demand & supply of equities rather than try to predict how investors will feel a few months from now. Over the next few days, I’ll be monitoring that demand & supply to see if any bounces are just the dead cat variety.